Dan Eisner's Rate Prediction
After enduring hauntingly high interest and mortgage rates — they're finally creeping back down the wall.
Even after the BoC's recent 'monster' rate cut, borrowing costs remain unsettlingly high, straining household budgets, cooling housing markets, and dampening consumer spending and business confidence.
We're seeing an economic cooldown amid a state of excess supply, with more being produced than consumed. As restrictive interest rates work their black magic up through months of lagging indicators, this imbalance could further erode Canada's economic growth.
That's not good news — though a silver lining news could be faster (and deeper) prime rate cuts from the BoC.
However, the recent U.S. election results (a repeat Trump presidency) may cast some shade onto Canada's rate agenda.
If U.S. growth in 2025 surpasses expectations, trade tariffs on Canadian imports are imposed, and inflation increases, there are potentially significant economic repercussions for Canada that may impact our (rate) way forward (I explain further below).
The weakening economic factors playing into this rate-cut cycle.
Canada's headline inflation rate came in below 'target' in September. Much sooner than anticipated.
Inflation cooled to 1.6% in September from August's 2.0% — a huge factor in the BoC's bigger rate cut.
This latest favourable headline inflation reading is thanks to base-year effects for gas (the price increase for this CPI component was much higher last year, which makes this September's increase look lower in comparison). The items excluding gas rose about the same as last month, with groceries still logging a faster pace than the headline at 2.4%.
Keep in mind that just because Canada's pace of average price increases has fallen below the BoC's target, that doesn't mean things are suddenly cheaper for Canadians. According to Stats Canada:
- Compared to last September 2021, the CPI rose 12.7%
- Rent today is +21.0% costlier nationally
- Food purchased from stores is +20.7% more expensive, increasing substantially during this same 3-year period
There's now a line drawn in the pumpkin patch: Cooling interest rates could help give households some needed relief when looking over bills at the kitchen table (as long as the inflation rate continues to behave).
And, the BoC's just-released consumer and business surveys show inflation expectations are continuing to improve, adding more fuel to its rate-cutting rationale.
Weakening Canadian labour market.
The October unemployment rate remains unchanged from last month at 6.5%, but the underlying numbers don't exude 'stability.'
With a gain of 15K jobs (less than the 27K expected), the total jobs created didn't (once again) match up to the continued brisk pace of Canadian population growth and growing labour force, with an employment rate that's been on a downward trend since February 2023.
Wage inflation also gained 0.3%, going from last month's 4.6% to October's 4.9%. This upside surprise is sure to bug inflation watchers, but as a lagging indicator, is unlikely to sway the BoC from its current rate-decline mood.
Economic growth is projected to underwhelm.
Despite a slight uptick in Q2, GDP (Gross Domestic Product) forecasts for the rest of 2024 look a little scarier, keeping to the long shadow cast by rapidly higher rates. The Bank of Canada has revised its Q3 prediction downward to 1.5%, but the reality is still expected to undershoot that figure.
The BoC stakes its 2025 growth projection at 2.1%; economists expect a much lower print of around 1.5%.
Canada's per capita GDP also fell again for the 5th straight quarter in 2024 — already far below our economic potential, considering the population increases our nation has seen in the last couple of years.
Canadian housing markets.
So far, nationally, housing markets have had a zombie-like response to the first few rate cuts, keeping home prices relatively stable for now. Sudden housing fervour could add to the shelter cost inflation basket and work against the rate cuts to halt or pause them.
Will new mortgage rules recently dropped by the federal government spur more housing activity this year or into 2025?
The potential for economic jump-scares is never completely out of sight:
- If Canada's rate agenda diverges by more than 1.0% from the U.S. Federal Reserve, it could impact our dollar for an inflationary effect
- Oil prices cracking the $100 ceiling due to global conflict or increased demand would raise business input costs that could be passed on to consumers (currently, oil prices are nowhere near that height)
- Impacted supply chains due to global conflict, weather events, labour strikes, or trade wars could result in higher input costs passed onto consumer prices
U.S. economy and rate-cut pace.
Like it or not, our countries' economies are closely linked, including the impact of the two rate agendas on the Canadian dollar.
With an incoming Trump presidency, some experts caution that U.S. economic growth may rev up, and 'immigration and tariff proposals' and implied tax cuts could result in supply or demand shocks that increase U.S. (and Canadian) inflation once again.
(U.S. economic growth could also have a positive effect on Canadian growth, but higher inflation would complicate things.)
The U.S. Fed has a dual mandate of maintaining lower inflation and a strong job market (vs. the BoC's sole 'inflation' mandate) — if it's forced to hold off on further rate cuts for a time, it could open up a more significant rate spread between the countries for a negative and inflationary effect here and on the CDN dollar.
Just because the economy is humming in the U.S. doesn't mean we'll do the same here, especially if tariffs (duties imposed on imported or exported goods) of 10-20% are introduced. Canada does about 75% of its export business with the U.S., and interruptions and higher prices could significantly slow growth.
That means the Bank of Canada may have to weigh combating higher inflation vs. sparking the economy when deciding on rate cuts in 2025 and beyond.
Despite the abovementioned concerns, the previous Trump presidency valued lower interest rates and inflation — so time will tell how the transition will shake out for Canadians at the kitchen table.
What will happen at the next rate meeting on December 11?
With one double-cut slipped under the door, some experts are calling for another one at the last BoC meeting of 2024.
I'm not ready to go beyond another 0.25% cut for that decision. Rates need to come down, but going too fast risks flaring inflation once again — especially with new U.S.-related concerns on the economic horizon.
(We've seen a quadruple hike of 1.0% in Canada during the past two years, though that sizable jump down is less likely to happen.)
Where will rates go in 2025?
I predict another 1.25% in BoC rate cuts coming by the end of 2025.
Assuming inflation continues to toe the line, BoC rate drops of at least 0.25% per meeting will likely resume through Q1 of 2025 (at least).
For months, I held a forecast of Canadian prime rates falling from peak by about 1.5% into the first quarter of next year and continuing to fall another 0.50% — for a 2.0% drop in total (to a 3.0% BoC resting rate).
I recently revised that forecast for a resting BoC rate of 2.50% for a total prime rate drop of 2.5% by the end of 2025, and I'll hold it there until we see how markets (and nerves) settle from the recent U.S. election news.
The neutral rate?
Many economists currently gauge the BoC neutral rate to be around 2.75% (where the economy is neither stimulated nor repressed), and rates might need to go lower to stimulate an economy dragged down by an intense hike schedule over two years.
Is there a danger that the prime rate could increase, despite talk of more cuts?
There's always that danger, though the widespread economic softening already underfoot makes it unlikely for at least the next few months as rate cuts work their way through the economy.
A year from now, we hope to have much lower rates and wonder where the economy will go from there.